Joey Gerard's - A Bartolotta Supper Club Menu

Introducing the menu at Joey Gerard's - A Bartolotta Supper Club

Joey Gerard's offers a modern take on the classic Wisconsin supper club, where hearty dishes meet warm, inviting ambiance. Located in Greendale, WI, this restaurant shines with generous portions and thoughtfully prepared meals. Highlights include the iconic Bacon Wrapped Scallops drizzled with a rich lemon butter sauce, and the celebrated Fried Seafood Basket, both praised for their precise cooking and bold flavors. The menu embraces traditional supper club staples like prime rib and lamb, expertly cooked to perfection. Attention to detail extends beyond the plate—guests often start with a nostalgic relish tray, a rare treat that enriches the dining experience. Pair these offerings with an extensive selection of cocktails and fine wines, set in a cozy, bustling atmosphere where attentive, personal service makes every visit special. Whether for anniversaries or simple indulgence, Joey Gerard’s balances comfort and elegance with every bite.